In a fascinating perspective piece, Matt Bivens and colleagues explain that the combination of struggle and restraint leads to death not because of hypoxia, but because of acidosis.
The sequence is something like this: exertion or struggle results in an acidotic state -> restraint reduces respiratory ability, especially when held prone or weight is applied to back or chest -> acidosis worsens with the potential for cardiac arrhythmia and arrest.
In this setting, “I can’t breathe” does not mean that there is no air movement over the vocal cords but that respiration is impaired, much as it is in asthma or obstructive lung disease.
Use of sedation in this setting reduces respiration even further, worsening acidosis and risking death. It’s not hypoxia that kills; it’s acidosis.
Bivens M, Jaeger E, Weedn V. Handcuffs and Unexpected Deaths — “I Can’t Breathe” as a Medical Emergency. NEJM 2024; 391:2068-9. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp2407162
